OPINIONS
Tue 22 Oct 2024 5:08 pm - Jerusalem Time
Netanyahu said Israel won't resettle Gaza. His own ministers tell a different story
Rachel Fink
It might have been possible to dismiss the 'Preparing to Resettle Gaza' conference as the collective rantings of a fringe group of extremists with no actual power to affect policy, were it not for one thing: the lineup of speakers
Israel's far-right National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir dancing at the conference calling for Jewish resettlement of the Gaza Strip, near the Israeli-Gaza border, southern Israel, on Monday.
On Monday morning, hundreds of settlement-supporting Israelis, many with their gaggle of young children in tow, headed down to the southern border for a special Sukkot-themed celebration. Over two days, they gathered in temporary huts to discuss permanent resettlement. Of the Gaza Strip, that is. "Every single sliver of it," as one speaker declared.
Hers was just one of a slew of comments jockeying for the title of most incendiary statement made during the event. "We will sun ourselves on the sandy beaches of the Gazan coastline," another contender proclaimed. Conference organizer Daniella Weiss has bigger plans. "We know from the Bible that the real borders of Greater Israel are the Euphrates and the Nile," she said to the audience, who cheered enthusiastically. "And the sooner we make this a reality, the better."
The "from the river to the sea" crowd has nothing on Weiss, who vowed to make her messianic dreams come true within the next year. "You will see," she told a group of slightly bewildered foreign journalists. "Jews will go into Gaza and Arabs will disappear from Gaza."
It might have been possible to dismiss the entire event as just the collective rantings of a fringe group of extremists with no actual power to affect policy, were it not for one thing: the lineup of speakers. Because, one by one, some of Israel's most prominent politicians made their way to the stage to express support for resettlement.
"We have to speak to them in the only language they understand," said Likud MK Tally Gotliv, "Taking their land away from them."
"We will hit them where it hurts," her fellow party member May Golan threatened. "Anyone who uses their plot of land to plan another Holocaust will receive from us, with God's help, another Nakba that they will tell their children and their grandchildren about for the next 50 years."
National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir. Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich. Negev and Galilee Development Minister Yitzhak Wasserlauf. Religious Zionism MK Tzvi Succot. For hours, they mingled and danced and discussed. They posed for photos with adoring fans and gave press interviews to anyone who asked (except Haaretz). And they made their position quite clear – Make Gaza Jewish Again.
Their boss, it would seem, is inclined to disagree. Netanyahu has regularly rejected the idea of permanently occupying Gaza, calling it "off the table" and "unrealistic" in various interviews and speeches. Gotliv was asked about this discrepancy by a reporter at the conference, to which she replied, "The prime minister is very clear about the need for security. And settlement equals security. Period." Weiss fielded the "unrealistic" claim. "Oh, how I love that word," she exclaimed. "It's like a sweet treat for my ears. Because that's exactly what they told me about settling Judea and Samaria. So when they tell me settling in Gaza is unrealistic, I know it can be done."
It's possible the prime minister is telling the truth when he says he won't allow resettlement in Gaza and that Israel has no plans to displace its civilian population, but it is awfully hard to hear him over the din of voices – all coming from inside his own coalition – who are declaring the very opposite to be true. Perhaps he should speak a little
Tags
MORE FROM OPINIONS
The picture with all the pain!
Ibrahim Melhem
Depriving the Palestinian people of their rights is a betrayal of humanitarian principles
op-ed - Al-Quds dot com
Specifications of the "new Trumpism" and the question of the future
Asaad Abdulrahman
China's unwavering support for the Palestinian people amid fighting and humanitarian crisis
Written by Ambassador Zeng Jixin, Director of the Office of the People's Republic of China to the State of Palestine
Guest Opinion: Uncovering facts about Xinjiang as a BRI hub
by Hazem Samir - Source: Xinhua
Guest Opinion: False narratives about Xinjiang won't halt its development
Guest Opinion: Journey through Xinjiang -- unveiling the truth
Source: Xinhua
Gaza remains the greatest pain
op-ed "AlQuds" dot com
Non-final agreement
Hamada Faraana
Which East do we want?
Abdullah Janahi
Israel’s Trump Delusion: Why Netanyahu’s Ambition to Remake the Middle East Is Unlikely to Succeed
Foreign Affairs
How Biden Can Salvage Middle East Peace—and His Legacy
Foreign Affairs
China's unwavering support for the Palestinian people amid fighting and humanitarian crisis
Written by Ambassador Zeng Jixin, Director of the Office of the People's Republic of China to the State of Palestine
Lebanon's will
op-ed - Al-Quds dot com
Winter.. A season of suffering in Gaza
op-ed "AlQuds" dot com
Which East do we want?
Iyad Barghouti
What does the ICC decision mean for the leaders of the occupying state?
Rassem Obaidat
Israel increases the rate of killing Palestinians
op-ed "AlQuds" dot com
Providing urgent and immediate protection for Palestinian children
Sari Al Kidwa
Facts about Palestine's accession to ICC and the arrest warrants
Dr. Dalal Saeb Erekat
Share your opinion
Netanyahu said Israel won't resettle Gaza. His own ministers tell a different story