OPINIONS

Fri 06 Sep 2024 2:46 pm - Jerusalem Time

Defying the myths and the lies: Three myths and lies

Myth and Lie #1: If israel doesn't stay in Gaza, October 7th can happen again!

Truth #1: If there were 15 tanks at the border and 3 assault helicopters in the air on Oct. 7, this wouldn't have happened. israel is not facing the Russian army. The second crossing of the border, it's Hamas, and now Hamas's military capabilities have been significantly destroyed. The IDF was not on the border on October 7th and this is first and foremost the fault of the decision-makers and the army and the intelligence, but this is also the result of two decades of turning the Israel Defense Army into the Israeli occupation police in the West Bank. That's where the army was located on October 7, and not on the border of israel The Israeli army has the full capability to protect the borders of Israel from the Israeli side of those borders.

Myth and Lie No. 2: Israeli Control of Philadelphia Axis Essential for Security israel !

Truth No. 2: Alon Ben David, the military correspondent of israel channel 13 reported this week, along with others, that the Israeli army had not located a single tunnel penetrating the Philadelphia Axis into Egypt. Before the Egyptian coup in which Abdel Fateh al-Sisi became Egypt's president, there were hundreds of smuggling tunnels between Gaza and Egypt that smuggled everything, including weapons and weapons manufacturing materials and tunnel-digging machines. There was even an official Hamas government office in charge of the tunnels affairs from which tunnels could be rented for private business use. Egypt under Sisi has claimed that they have closed all the tunnels and it seems to be true. There is information that at the Rafah crossing many smuggling did take place through bribery. The Philadelphia corridor must be secured and sealed in a chemically way and can be done on the Egyptian side of the line. If israel does not trust the Egyptians to do so, I believe that in negotiating with Egypt there could be an agreement to place American inspectors on the axis on the Egyptian side to ensure the sealing of the axis. Israeli forces located along the corridor sat like ducks for Hamas armed forces.

Myth and Lie No. 3: You can defeat a military Hamas!

Truth No. 3: Hamas is much more than a military force and a government structure. Hamas is an idea and ideology and Hamas was imbibed in Palestinian society as part of resistance to Israeli occupation and control. Ideas and ideologies in general cannot be defeated by military means alone. Furthermore, there is no military solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and he never had a military solution. The way to defeat ideology and idea is to make better ideologies and ideas successful to the public that believes in them. The better idea to defeat Hamas is freedom, liberty, dignity and self-determination for the Palestinian people. Here it is also important to remember that if Palestinians have no freedom, liberty, dignity, and self-determination, Israel will have no security, and Palestinians need to understand that if Israel has no security, Palestinians will not have freedom, freedom, dignity and self--determination. We all need security - including the Palestinians.

Tags

Share your opinion

Defying the myths and the lies: Three myths and lies

MORE FROM OPINIONS

Aggression everywhere

op-ed - Al-Quds dot com

Israel.. The approach of "mass slaughter" leads to "self-suicide"!

Asaad Abdul Rahman

North Gaza: Hunger, massacres and siege

Bahaa Rahal

What is happening in the Gaza Strip is part of a genocide plan.

Sari Al Qudwa

Seven points in understanding Zionist extremism

Bakr Abu Bakr

Is a ceasefire approaching?

Jawad Al-Anani

Our Weak Memory: Draft Laws to End UNRWA’s Work Are Not New

Sami Mshasha

Three upcoming scenarios that will determine the future of the region

Ahmed Al-Hila

Rashid Khalidi, America’s foremost scholar of Palestine, is retiring: ‘I don’t want to be a cog in the machine any more’

The Guardian

Gaza: A never-ending cycle of death

op-ed - Al-Quds dot com

Has Hamas become a burden on the Arab world after it caused the crushing of Hezbollah?

Translation for "Al-Quds" dot com

Israel between the media of victory and its absence

walid Abdulhay

Messages of steadfastness from Gaza and the West Bank

op-ed - Al-Quds dot com

A year after the Al-Aqsa flood... Is it time for evaluation?

Hani Al Masry

Palestinian culture is a soft power in the face of genocide

Dr. Sarah Mohammed Al-Shammas

Here's the Truth: It Is the Lack of a Two-State Solution That Most Threatens Israel

Common Dreams

The hardest year: What changed in us and in them?

Dr. Ahmed Rafiq Awad

A Wider Middle East War Can Still Be Stopped

International Crisis Group

‘Dahiyeh Doctrine’ returns to Dahiyeh

Aljazeera

Iran is increasingly desperate, retired US general says

Politico