OPINIONS
Sun 10 Nov 2024 9:09 am - Jerusalem Time
Threats and risks of searching for an alternative to UNRWA
On October 28, 2024, the Israeli Knesset voted overwhelmingly in favor of a resolution submitted by members of the Likud party, banning the activities of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees (UNRWA) within the territories controlled by Israel.
The decision prohibits UNRWA from carrying out any activity or providing any services in the areas controlled by Israel, and will come into effect after 90 days from its date, which threatens to disrupt essential humanitarian assistance to approximately 2.2 million people in Gaza, who are suffering from difficult humanitarian conditions due to the blockade, hunger, lack of medicine, and the ongoing genocidal war for more than a year, in addition to endangering humanitarian assistance in the West Bank, East Jerusalem, Lebanon, and Syria.
The decision has sparked widespread concern among humanitarian organizations, who have warned of disastrous consequences for Palestinian refugees, especially in the absence of an alternative to UNRWA. UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres, in a letter to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, stressed that banning UNRWA would have a significant impact on the Palestinians, and that Israel, as an occupying power, was obligated to meet their needs. In response, Israeli Ambassador Danny Danon said that Israel would continue to provide humanitarian aid, accusing UNRWA of bias in favor of Hamas. The Israeli Coordinator of Government Activities in the Territories (COGAT) announced its support for the work of other UN agencies in Gaza, while the United Nations denied the existence of any alternative that would match UNRWA’s role.
In conjunction with these developments, Norway announced its intention to submit a request to the UN General Assembly to obtain a legal opinion from the International Court of Justice on Israel’s obligation to facilitate the entry of aid provided to the Palestinians by international organizations, whether from the United Nations or other countries. Despite Norway’s sincere intentions, which recognize the Palestinian state and the rights of the Palestinian people, the ongoing debate about finding an alternative to UNRWA poses a major threat to the Palestinian refugee issue, as the agency’s mission is not limited to providing humanitarian aid only, but is also considered a symbol of the Palestinians’ right of return. On the other hand, talking about an alternative role for UNRWA, especially in the Israeli context, represents a major challenge under the current circumstances, as the Israeli occupation will inevitably exploit the humanitarian aid file as a pressure card on the Palestinians instead of adhering to the principles of international humanitarian law, which it has never respected.
The ban reflects the desire of the extreme right-wing movements in Israel to establish the concept of Jerusalem as the unified capital of Israel, free of refugee camps, UNRWA offices, and any evidence of Palestinian identity. There seems to be a clear trend towards promoting the idea of displacement and settlement of Palestinian refugees in neighboring countries such as Jordan, Lebanon, and Syria, which contributes to reducing international support for the Palestinians’ right to self-determination.
The decision to ban UNRWA comes as part of a broader Israeli-American plan aimed at eliminating the agency’s role and ultimately liquidating the historical rights of Palestinian refugees. The US administration has already begun exploring alternatives to UNRWA, according to statements by US State Department spokesman Matthew Miller in March 2024 about Washington’s search for alternative agencies to UNRWA to provide aid. It is most likely that these agencies will be of American nationality, as part of a US strategy aimed at consolidating and expanding its influence, in the face of the rise of China and Russia in the region.
This decision constitutes a new link in the chain of Israeli efforts and endeavors to reduce the role of UNRWA and liquidate the rights of Palestinian refugees. As the ban is about to be implemented, it becomes necessary to strengthen Palestinian, Arab and international action to protect UNRWA and support the rights of refugees. The next stage requires concerted efforts to break this decision and emphasize the importance of UNRWA as a fundamental pillar for providing humanitarian aid and defending the rights of refugees in the face of the ongoing escalation of the occupation, away from any pressure or political blackmail.
Tags
MORE FROM OPINIONS
The luxury of dialogue under the burden of the crimes of genocide and ethnic cleansing
Jamal Zaqout
How Iran Sees the Path to Peace
Foreign Affairs
‘The ICC’s findings so far have only scratched the surface’
972+ Magazine
The fate of the unity of the arenas after the ceasefire agreement between Israel and Hezbollah
Retired Major General: Ahmed Issa
“Promoting Chaos and Sustaining Occupation”: The US-Israeli Hegemony Project in the Middle East
Marwan Emil Toubasi
Settlement plans in Gaza and the continuation of the genocide
Bahaa Rahal
So that the Palestinians do not pay the price of settlements in the region
Dr. Ahmed Rafiq Awad
Washington Post: Netanyahu reached an agreement with Hezbollah, so why not with Hamas?
Translation for "Al-Quds" dot com
Rashid Khalidi: This genocide 'worse than any phase of Palestinian history' | UpFront
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1_SkF1-rDl0
Confession from within
op-ed - Al-Quds dot com
A proposal to President Mahmoud Abbas
Lawyer Ziad Abu Ziad
The picture with all the pain!
Ibrahim Melhem
Depriving the Palestinian people of their rights is a betrayal of humanitarian principles
op-ed - Al-Quds dot com
Specifications of the "new Trumpism" and the question of the future
Asaad Abdulrahman
China's unwavering support for the Palestinian people amid fighting and humanitarian crisis
Written by Ambassador Zeng Jixin, Director of the Office of the People's Republic of China to the State of Palestine
Guest Opinion: Uncovering facts about Xinjiang as a BRI hub
by Hazem Samir - Source: Xinhua
Guest Opinion: False narratives about Xinjiang won't halt its development
Guest Opinion: Journey through Xinjiang -- unveiling the truth
Source: Xinhua
Gaza remains the greatest pain
op-ed "AlQuds" dot com
Non-final agreement
Hamada Faraana
Share your opinion
Threats and risks of searching for an alternative to UNRWA