OPINIONS
Fri 03 May 2024 4:25 pm - Jerusalem Time
Biden and Blinken’s Timorous Israel Policy
By James W. Carden
Long after the current administration passes from the scene, President Joseph R. Biden and Secretary of State Antony Blinken will be remembered not for their bumbling, embarrassing encounters with the Chinese, nor for their steadfast refusal to negotiate a peaceful settlement with the Russians, which set off a disastrous war that has claimed hundreds of thousands of lives.
Instead, they will likely be remembered as the abettors of Israel’s transformation of Gaza into an abattoir, and will leave a legacy as bloodstained as Richard Nixon and Henry Kissinger’s.
But, to be fair, Nixon and Kissinger knew which country was theirs; they understood that the United States and Israel have distinct and vastly different interests. Indeed, it is little remembered today that as Secretary of State, Kissinger once ordered a reassessment of this so-called “special relationship.”
Lacking the sheen of Kissinger’s not inconsiderable wit and intellect, Tony Blinken, a protege of Marty Peretz, erstwhile publisher of the New Republic and an ideological Zionist, may one day be remembered as his generation’s Robert McNamara: a bland bureaucrat carrying out the obscene orders of his commander-in-chief.
As if more were needed to bolster such a judgment, this week, after acknowledging that five Israeli military units had engaged in gross human rights abuses, the Biden administration signaled it will not apply the Leahy Law—which prohibits aid to militaries that have committed human rights abuses—to Israel. It would be hard to improve upon the following headline from the Hill: “US finds Israeli military units violated human rights; withholds consequences.”
In an incredible performance this Monday at Foggy Bottom, the State Department spokesman Vedant Patel (yet another foreign-born bureaucrat who clearly knows little about the country he is paid to represent) ran cover for the Israelis once again, claiming that the IDF was now in line with Leahy and all is well.
Yet, given Israel’s widespread, heavily documented crimes, including the deployment of AI systems such as Lavender AI systematically to terrorize the Palestinian population, the application of Leahy would seem a mere slap on the wrist. Yet Blinken and Biden have deemed even symbolic measures of disapproval of Israel’s rampage as too great a burden on Tel Aviv.
If Blinken and Biden were serious about stopping the carnage, they could have applied section 6201 of the Foreign Assistance Act, which prohibits security assistance to countries blocking humanitarian aid. In late March, a group of Democratic senators and congressmen called on the administration to do just that, writing, in a letter to the President,
Federal law is clear, and, given the urgency of the crisis in Gaza, and the repeated refusal of Prime Minister Netanyahu to address U.S. concerns on this issue, immediate action is necessary to secure a change in policy by his government.
If Biden and Blinken were serious, they would have applied Leahy and enforced the terms of the Arms Control Export Act, the U.S. War Crimes Act and the Genocide Convention Implementation Act; if they were serious, they would have supported South Africa’s case against Israel in the International Court of Justice; if they were serious, they would not have instructed UN Ambassador Linda Thomas-Greenfield repeatedly to veto measures in the UN Security Council calling for a ceasefire; if they were serious, they would call for the International Criminal Court to issue arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, Defense Minister Yoav Gallant, and others.
And yet, even now, over 90 attorneys within the Biden administration are drafting a letter to the cowardly Attorney General Merrick Garland calling for a halt on military aid to Israel. According to a report in POLITICO on Monday, the lawyers contend that “Israel likely violated U.S. statutes including the Arms Export Control Act and Leahy Laws as well as the Geneva Conventions prohibiting disproportionate attacks on civilian populations.”
What will come of it?
Not a thing. Because Biden and Blinken act not as American statesmen, beholden to American laws in the furtherance of American interests—but rather, as adjunct members of the Israeli war cabinet.
Tags
MORE FROM OPINIONS
Brief Talk
Ibrahim Melhem
US focused on hunting down Hamas chief Yahya Sinwar, in bid to end Gaza war
Middle East Eye
Video: Why Israel Is in Deep Trouble
JOHN J. MEARSHEIMERMAY
Palestine and Israel... from the Jewish Holocaust to the Palestinian Holocaust
Ibrahim Abrash
The least that can be said
Ibrahim Melhem
The Limits of Moralism in Israel and Gaza
Ross Douthat
The Limits of the Biden-Netanyahu ‘Dispute’... Above the Rubble of Rafah
Eyad Abu Shakra
French academic: Biden has declared himself a Zionist since 1973
Translation for "Al-Quds" dot com
Under the Pretext of “Antisemitism”, the Suppression of the Palestinian People is Accompanied by an Attempt to Suppress the Defense of their Cause
YAANI.fr
Podcast: 7 Months on, How Would a Breakthrough look? Ehud Olmert, Dr Nasser Alkidwa & Thomas Friedman
Ramallah - "Al-Quds" dot com
What Hamas Wants in Postwar Gaza
Foreign Affairs
Hebrew Media: What is behind Biden's threat to stop supplying weapons to Israel?
Institute for National Security Studies
Biden’s war on Gaza is now a war on truth and the right to protest
Jonathan Cook
Gaza is the greatest test liberalism has faced since 1945. And it is failing
Middle East Eye
Student protests upend hegemony on Israel and Palestine forever
Middle East Eye
What will follow from the start of the attack on Rafah, and where is the movement heading in the Middle East?
Translation for "Al-Quds" dot com
They Used to Say Arabs Can’t Have Democracy Because It’d Be Bad for Israel. Now the U.S. Can’t Have It Either.
The Intercept
Netanyahu and Hamas are playing politics over a Gaza truce
Prospects
Rafah invasion: With defeat in sight, how can Netanyahu declare victory?
Middle East Eye
War on Gaza: Western powers never believed in a rules-based order
Middle East Eye
Share your opinion
Biden and Blinken’s Timorous Israel Policy